I feel like the
transformation of Frankenstein’s monster within visual media says a lot about
the film adaptation of novels. Often times in adapting stories for the screen,
the adapter opts for the visual appeal or aesthetic over everything else—that’s
the medium. In the case of the 1931 film of Frankenstein, I think it was
adapted to fit into the genre of “monster films” rather than doing an actually
faithful representation of the themes of the book. While the book obviously is
about monsters, the genre of “monster films” generally focuses on the monster
as the main “event” of the film, and the appearance of the monster is essential
to the success of the film. The appearance of the monster would often appear on
promotional art as well, and creating an iconic appearance is exactly what the
1931 film did. The monster has changed significantly from the novel—the main
difference is that the monster in the novel is extremely articulate and
educated, an entire section of the book is dedicated to him detailing his
experiences within the world thus far. The monster in the novel serves as a
mouthpiece for the way that the Other is coded in society. This context is
removed from the film adaptation for a new figure of the monster who is simply
there to frighten or to visually excite the viewer. Gone is the cultural
subtext, which is replaced for a cheap thrill instead. The name change from
nameless to “Frankenstein” also reflects this change. Essentially, the monster
as a character between the novel and the film adaptation is a shift between the
monster previously being a reflection of larger society to a singular character that
is devoid of the previous meanings. Giving him a name makes him a mere
individual rather than the mosaic of things that he represents. This is why I
think the name of “Frankenstein” to refer to the monster has remained so
pervasive—it’s easier to think of the monster as an individual character, but
it’s harder for people to grasp the concept that the monster is representative
of multiple experiences.
Comments
Post a Comment